Translating Classical Buddhism to Modern English

The Long Discourses

Part II

(一四) 佛說長阿含 第二分 釋提桓因問經第十 14. The Questions Asked by Śakra the Lord of Gods
如是我聞: 一時,佛在摩竭國、菴婆羅村北、毘陀山、因陀娑羅窟中。 1. Thus I have heard:1 One time, the Buddha was staying north of the village of Āmra of Magadha in Indraśaila Cave on Mount Vaidehaka.2
Lord Śakra Visits the Buddha
爾時,釋提桓因發微妙善心,欲來見佛: 「今,我當往至世尊所!」 2. It was then that Śakra the Lord of Gods had a wonderful, good thought about wanting to come see the Buddha: “Now, I will go visit the Bhagavān!”
時,諸忉利天聞釋提桓因發妙善心,欲詣佛所,即尋詣帝釋,白言: 「善哉,帝釋!發妙善心,欲詣如來。 我等亦樂侍從詣世尊所。」 3. When the Trāyastriṃśa gods heard that Śakra the Lord of Gods had a wonderful, good thought about wanting to come visit the Buddha, they went immediately to Lord Śakra and said, “Excellent, Lord Śakra! You’ve had a wonderful, good thought about wanting to visit the Tathāgata. We too would like to come along as attendants and visit the Bhagavān.”3
時,釋提桓因即告執樂神般遮翼曰: 「我今欲詣世尊所。 汝可俱行,此忉利諸天亦當與我俱詣佛所。」 4. Śakra the Lord of Gods then told the gandharva Pañcaśikha,4 “I’m going now to visit the Bhagavān. You can walk with me and these Trāyastriṃśa gods who are also going to visit the Buddha.”
對曰:「唯然!」 時,般遮翼持琉璃琴,於帝釋前忉利天眾中鼓琴供養。 5. Pañcaśikha replied, “Very well.” He then took his cymophane lute and strummed it at the front of the assembly of Trāyastriṃśa gods as an offering.
時,釋提桓因、忉利諸天、及般遮翼於法堂上忽然不現。 譬如力士屈伸臂頃,至摩竭國北、毘陀山中。 6. Śakra the Lord of Gods, the Trāyastriṃśa gods, and Pañcaśikha then suddenly disappeared from up in the Dharma [Meeting] Hall. In the time it takes a strong man to flex his arm, they arrived on Mount Vaidehaka to the north of Magadha.
爾時,世尊入火焰三昧,彼毘陀山同一火色。 時國人見,自相謂言: 「此毘陀山同一火色。 將是如來諸天之力!」 7. At the time, the Bhagavān had entered the samādhi of blazing fire,5 and Mount Vaidehaka had the same color as a flame. The people in the countryside who saw it said to each other, “This Mount Vaidehaka has the same color as a flame. It must be the power of the Tathāgata or the gods!”
時,釋提桓因告般遮翼曰: 「如來、至真甚難得覩,而能垂降此閑靜處,寂默、無聲、禽獸為侶。 此處常有諸大神天侍衛世尊。 汝可於前鼓琉璃琴,娛樂世尊。 吾與諸天尋於後往!」 8. Śakra the Lord of Gods then told Pañcaśikha, “It’s very difficult to look upon the Tathāgata, the Arhat, but we can go down to this place of seclusion that’s quiet, without a sound, and where the animals gather. The Bhagavān is constantly attended to by great spirits and gods there. You may take the lead and play music with your cymophane lute to delight the Bhagavān. The gods and I will be right behind you!”
對曰:「唯然!」 即受教已,持琉璃琴於先詣佛。 去佛不遠,鼓琉璃琴,以偈歌曰: 9. Pañcaśikha replied, “Very well.” He did as he was instructed, going first to visit the Bhagavān with his cymophane lute in hand. When he was not far away from the Buddha, he played his lute and sang these lyrics:
  • 「跋陀禮汝父;
    汝父甚端嚴!
    生汝時吉祥;
    我心甚愛樂!
  • “Bhadrā, I honor your father;6
    Your father is so dignified!
    He was so lucky when you were born;
    My heart desires you so much!
  • 本以小因緣,
    欲心於中生。
    展轉遂增廣,
    如供養羅漢。
  • For some minor reason in the past,
    The desire for you was born in me.
    It developed and grew larger,
    Like an offering to an arhat.
  • 釋子專四禪,
    常樂於閑居。
    正意求甘露;
    我專念亦爾。
  • Śākyans focus on four meditations,
    Always happy living in seclusion.
    They pursue the immortal with right thinking;
    And my thoughts are focused in the same way.7
  • 能仁發道心,
    必欲成正覺。
    我今求彼女,
    必欲會亦爾。
  • Śākyamuni set his heart on enlightenment,
    Sure he’d achieve the correct awakening.
    Now, if I were to pursue that woman,
    I’d be sure to join with her, too.
  • 我心生染著;
    愛好不捨離。
    欲捨不能去;
    如象為鈎制。
  • My heart is affected by attachment;
    I haven’t renounced the love of beauty.
    I’d like to renounce it, but I can’t leave it;
    I’m like an elephant led by the hook.8
  • 如熱遇涼風,
    如渴得冷泉,
    如取涅槃者,
    如水滅於火。
  • It’s like a cool wind when it’s hot,
    Like finding a cool spring when thirsty,
    Like someone choosing nirvāṇa,
    Or like water dousing a fire.
  • 如病得良醫
    飢者得美食。
    充足生快樂
    如羅漢遊法。
  • It’s like someone sick finding a doctor
    Or a starving person getting a fine meal.
    They’re filled with happiness
    Like an arhat exploring the Dharma.9
  • 如象被深鈎
    而猶不肯伏。
    𩣺突難禁制,
    放逸不自止。
  • It’s like an elephant that’s hooked deeply
    But still refuses to submit.
    Charging around and hard to control,
    The reckless don’t stop themselves.10
  • 猶如清涼池
    眾花覆水上。
    疲熱象沐浴,
    舉身得清涼。
  • It’s like a refreshing pond
    Covered by assorted water lilies.
    Hot and exhausted elephants bathe there,
    Cooling off their whole bodies.11
  • 我前後所施,
    供養諸羅漢。
    世有福報者
    盡當與彼供。
  • I’ll give gifts, one after another,
    To support the arhats.
    This world’s rewards for such merit
    Will all be given as gifts to her.12
  • 汝死當共死。
    汝無我活為?
    寧使我身死;
    不能無汝存。
  • When you die, I’ll die with you.
    How could I live on with you gone?
    I would rather die myself;
    It’s impossible to exist without you.13
  • 忉利天之主!
    釋今與我願!
    稱汝禮節具;
    汝善思察之。」
  • Lord of the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven!
    Śakra, grant me my wish now!
    You’ve an honorable character;
    You’ll consider it well.”14
爾時,世尊從三昧起,告般遮翼言: 「善哉!善哉!般遮翼,汝能以清淨音和琉璃琴稱讚如來。 琴聲、汝音,不長不短,悲和哀婉,感動人心。 汝琴所奏,眾義備有,亦說欲縛,亦說梵行,亦說沙門,亦說涅槃。」 10. The Bhagavān then roused from his samādhi and told Pañcaśikha, “Good, Pañcaśikha, good! You’re able to praise the Tathāgata with your clear voice and harmonious cymophane lute. The sound of both your lute and voice are neither long or short, and their compassion and gracefulness moves people’s hearts. Your song is replete with many meanings and explains the bonds of desire, the religious life, the ascetic, and nirvāṇa!”
爾時,般遮翼白佛言: 「我念世尊昔鬱鞞羅、尼連禪水邊,阿遊波陀、尼俱律樹下初成佛道時,有尸漢陀天大將子及執樂天王女,共於一處,但設欲樂。 我於爾時見其心爾,即為作頌,頌說欲縛,亦說梵行,亦說沙門,亦說涅槃。 11. Pañcaśikha then said to the Buddha, “I remember when the Bhagavān became a buddha sitting beneath the goatherd’s banyan tree on the bank of the Nairañjanā River in Uruvilvā.15 The great god general’s son Śikhaṇḍin16 and the gandharva king’s daughter had a rendezvous just to enjoy themselves. I saw the way they were feeling at the time and composed this song. The lyrics explain the bonds of desire, and they explain the religious life, the ascetic, and nirvāṇa.
時,彼天女聞我偈已,舉目而笑語我言:『般遮翼!我未見如來,我曾於忉利天法講堂上,聞彼諸天稱讚如來,有如是德,有如是力。汝常懷信,親近如來,我今意欲與汝共為知識。』世尊!我時與一言之後,不復與語。」 12. “After she heard my song, the goddess raised her eyes, smiled, and said to me, ‘Pañcaśikha, I’ve never seen a Tathāgata, but I heard the other gods in the Trāyastriṃśa Dharma Meeting Hall praising the virtues and abilities possessed by the Tathāgata. You’ve always been faithful and close to the Tathāgata. I think I’d like to be friends with you.’ Bhagavān, after speaking with her that one time, I never spoke with her again.”
時,釋提桓因作是念:「此般遮翼已娛樂如來訖,我今寧可念於彼人。」時,天帝釋即念彼人。 13. Śakra the Lord of Gods then had this thought, “Now that Pañcaśikha has finished playing his music, I’d better keep him in mind.” Lord Śakra then remembered him.
時,般遮翼復生念言:「今天帝釋乃能念我。」即持琉璃琴詣帝釋所。 14. Pañcaśikha again thought, “Now Lord Śakra will remember me!” He then took his cymophane lute and went to Lord Śakra.
帝釋告曰:「汝以我名并稱忉利天意,問訊世尊:『起居輕利,遊步強耶?』」 15. Lord Śakra told him, “Praise the intent of the Trāyastriṃśa gods in my name. Go exchange these greetings with the Bhagavān, ‘Has your daily life been easy? Are you in good health?’”
時,般遮翼承帝釋教,即詣世尊所,頭面禮足,於一面住,白世尊言:「釋提桓因及忉利諸天故,遣我來問訊世尊:『起居輕利,遊步強耶?』」 16. Pañcaśikha accepted Lord Śakra’s instructions and went to the Bhagavān. He bowed his head at his feet and stood to one side. He said to the Bhagavān, “Śakra the Lord of Gods and the Trāyastriṃśa gods have sent me to exchange greetings with the Bhagavān: ‘Has your daily life been easy? Are you in good health?’”
世尊報曰:「使汝帝釋及忉利天壽命延長,快樂無患。所以然者?諸天、世人及阿須輪諸眾生等,皆貪壽命、安樂、無患。」 17. The Bhagavān replied, “May you, Lord Śakra, and the Trāyastriṃśa gods have long, happy, and untroubled lives. Why is that? The hosts of gods, worldly people, and asuras are all cherish their life spans, happiness, and lack of trouble.”
爾時,帝釋復自念言:「我等宜往禮覲世尊。」即與忉利諸天往詣佛所,頭面禮足,却住一面。時,帝釋白佛言:「不審我今去世尊遠近可坐?」 18. Lord Śakra again thought, “We ought to approach the Bhagavān and bow to him.” He then went to the Bhagavān with the Trāyastriṃśa gods. They bowed at the Buddha’s feet and withdrew to stand to one side. Lord Śakra then said to the Buddha, “Don’t mind us, Bhagavān. Should we sit nearby or at a distance?”
佛告帝釋曰:「汝天眾多,但近我坐。」 19. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “Your host of gods is large, but they can sit nearby.”
時,世尊所止因陀羅窟,自然廣博,無所障碍。爾時,帝釋與忉利諸天及般遮翼皆禮佛足,於一面坐, 20. The Bhagavān then made the Indrasāla Cave enlarge itself so that none of them were obstructed by it. Lord Śakra, the Trāyastriṃśa gods, and Pañcaśikha all bowed at the Buddha’s feet and sat to one side.
The Story of Gopaka and the Disciples
帝釋白佛言:「一時,佛在舍衛國婆羅門舍,爾時世尊入火焰三昧,我時以少因緣,乘千輻寶車,詣毘樓勒天王所,於空中過,見一天女叉手在世尊前立,我尋語彼女言:『若世尊三昧起者,汝當稱我名字,問訊世尊:起居輕利,遊步強耶?』不審彼女後竟為我達此心不?世尊!寧能憶此事不?」 21. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “One time, the Buddha was staying at a priest’s residence in Śrāvastī. At the time, the Bhagavān had entered the samādhi of blazing fire. For some reason, I was riding my thousand-spoked treasure chariot to visit Virūḍhaka. As I went by in the sky, I saw a goddess standing with her palms together in front of the Bhagavān. I immediately said to that goddess, ‘If the Bhagavān rouses from samādhi, you should exchange these greetings with the Bhagavān in my name: “Has your daily life been easy? Are you in good health?”’ I wondered later if she had conveyed this thought for me. Bhagavān, do you recall if she did?”
佛言:「憶耳!彼女尋以汝聲致問於我,吾從定起,猶聞汝車聲。」 22. The Buddha said, “I do remember it. That goddess immediately put the question to me with her goddess’s voice, and I roused from samādhi. It was like the sound of a woman’s chariot.”
帝釋白佛言:「昔者,我以少緣,與忉利諸天集在法堂,彼諸舊天皆作是言:『若如來出世,增益諸天眾,減損阿須輪眾。』今我躬見世尊,躬見自知,躬自作證,如來、至真出現於世,增益諸天眾,減損阿須輪眾。 23. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “In the past, I held a meeting for some reason with the Trāyastriṃśa gods in the Dharma [Meeting] Hall. Those gods back then had said, ‘If a Tathāgata arises in the world, the host of gods will increase and the host of asuras will diminish!’ Now that I see the Bhagavān in person, I personally see and know it myself. I’ve realized it myself: ‘The Tathāgata, the Arhat, has arisen in the world, and the host of gods are increasing, and the host of asuras are diminishing!’
此有瞿夷釋女,於世尊所淨修梵行,身壞命終,生忉利天宮,即為我子。忉利諸天皆稱言:『瞿夷大天子有大功德,有大威力。』 24. “Here, there was the Śākyan woman Gopikā who had purely cultivated the Bhagavān’s religious life. She was born in the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven’s palace as my son after her body broke up and her life ended. The Trāyastriṃśa gods all praised him, ‘The great godling Gopaka has great virtue and majesty!’
復有餘三比丘,於世尊所淨修梵行,身壞命終,生於卑下執樂神中,常日日來為我給使,瞿夷見已,以偈觸嬈曰: 25. “There were another three monks who had purely cultivated the Bhagavān’s religious life. They were born as inferior gandharva spirits after their bodies broke up and their lives ended. Every day, they came to serve us as messengers. When Gopaka saw them, he harassed them with these verses:
  • 「『汝為佛弟子,
    我本在家時,
    以衣食供養,
    禮拜致恭恪。
  • “‘Were you disciples of the Buddha
    When I was living at home in the past?
    I gave offerings of clothing and food,
    Bowing, venerating, and paying respect.
  • 汝等名何人?
    躬受佛教誡;
    淨眼之所說,
    汝不觀察之。
  • What were your human names when you
    Personally received the Buddha’s teaching?
    Those teachings were of pure vision,
    But there’s something you didn’t observe.
  • 我本禮敬汝,
    從佛聞上法;
    生三十三天,
    為帝釋作子。
  • In the past, I paid respects to you
    And heard the higher Dharma from the Buddha.
    When born in the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven,
    I became Lord Śakra’s son.
  • 汝等何不觀?
    我所有功德;
    本為女人身,
    今為帝釋子。
  • What didn’t you observe?
    The virtues that I had possessed.
    Formerly of a woman’s body,
    Now I’m Lord Śakra’s son.
  • 汝等本俱共,
    同修於梵行;
    今獨處卑賤,
    為吾等給使。
  • All of you were together in the past,
    Cultivating the same religious life.
    Now, you are alone in inferior places,
    Serving all of us here as messengers.
  • 本為弊惡行,
    今故受此報;
    獨處於卑賤,
    為吾等給使。
  • In the past, you hid bad conduct,
    So now you’ve gotten this reward.
    You are alone in inferior places,
    Serving all of us here as messengers.
  • 生此處不淨,
    為他所觸嬈;
    聞已當患厭,
    此處可厭患。
  • You’re born in this impure place,
    That for others is an insult.
    Hearing that will trouble you,
    For this place of yours is troublesome.
  • 從今當精勤,
    勿復為人使;
    二人勤精進,
    思惟如來法。
  • If you’re diligent from now on,
    You won’t become servants again!’
    Two of them diligently made effort,
    Thinking of the Tathāgata’s Dharma.
  • 捨彼所戀著,
    觀欲不淨行;
    欲縛不真實,
    誑惑於世間。
  • Discarding their attachments,
    They observed: ‘Desire is impure conduct.
    The bond of desire isn’t real;
    It tricks the people of the world.’
  • 如象離羈靽,
    超越忉利天;
    釋及忉利天,
    集法講堂上。
  • Like elephants free of leg bonds,
    They leapt to the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven
    While Śakra and the Trāyastriṃśa gods
    Gathered up in the Dharma Meeting Hall.
  • 彼已勇猛力,
    超越忉利天;
    釋歎未曾有,
    諸天亦見過。
  • They were courageous and strong,
    Leaping to the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven.
    Śakra lauded them as never before,
    And the gods also saw them pass away:
  • 此是釋迦子,
    超越忉利天;
    患厭於欲縛,
    瞿夷說此言。
  • ‘These are the Śākyan disciples
    Who leapt to the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven!
    They tired of being fettered by desire.’
    [Gopaka] spoke these words:
  • 摩竭國有佛,
    名曰釋迦文;
    彼子大失意,
    其後還得念。
  • ‘There’s a Buddha in Magadha
    Whose name is Śākyamuni.
    Those disciples were disappointing,
    But later regained their mindfulness.
  • 三人中一人,
    故為執樂神;
    二人見道諦,
    超越忉利天。
  • One person out of these three
    Therefore became a gandharva.
    The other two saw the truth of the path
    And leapt to the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven.
  • 世尊所說法,
    弟子不懷疑;
    俱共同聞法,
    二人勝彼一。
  • The Dharma the Bhagavān teaches
    Isn’t doubted by these disciples.
    They heard the same Dharma together,
    But two of them were better than one.
  • 自見殊勝已,
    皆生光音天;
    我觀見彼已,
    故來至佛所。』」
  • Their vision being much better,
    They were born as Ābhāsvara gods.
    When I observed them,
    They were going to the Buddha.’”
The Origin of Enmity and Conflict
帝釋白佛言:「願開閑暇,一決我疑。」 26. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “If you have a moment, I would like to clarify a doubt of mine.”
佛言:「隨 汝所問,吾當為汝一一演說。」 The Buddha said, “Go ahead and ask your questions. I will explain them for you, one by one.”
爾時,帝釋即白 佛言:「諸天、世人、乾沓和、阿須羅及餘眾生 等,盡與何結相應,乃至怨讐、刀杖相向?」 27. Lord Śakra then asked the Buddha, “What bonds do gods, worldly men, gandharvas, asuras, and other sentient beings all associate with that they become enemies and take up arms against each other?”
佛 告釋言:「怨結之生,皆由貪嫉,故使諸天、世 人、阿須羅、餘眾生等,刀杖相加。」 28. The Buddha told Śakra, “The arising of the bond of enmity has its origin in greed and jealousy. Therefore, it leads gods, worldly people, asuras, and other sentient beings to take up arms against each other.”
爾時,帝釋即 白佛言:「實爾!世尊!怨結之生,由貪嫉故,使 諸天、世人、阿須羅、餘眾生等,刀杖相加。我今 聞佛所說,疑網悉除,無復疑也, 29. Lord Śakra then said to the Buddha, “Indeed, it is, Bhagavān! The arising of the bond of enmity has its origin in greed and jealousy. Therefore, it leads gods, worldly people, asuras, and other sentient beings to take up arms against each other. Now that I’ve heard the Buddha’s explanation, a snare of doubt has been removed. I won’t wonder about it anymore.
但不解此 貪嫉之生,何由而起?何因何緣?誰為原首?從 誰而有?從誰而無?」 30. “But I don’t understand the arising of this greed and jealousy. Where do they come from? What are their causes and conditions? What’s their source? From what do they come to exist? From what do they cease to exist?”
佛告帝釋:「貪嫉之生,皆 由愛憎,愛憎為因,愛憎為緣,愛憎為首,從 此而有,無此則無。」 31. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “The arising of greed and jealousy have their origin in love and hate. Love and hate are their causes and conditions. Love and hate are their source. From them, they come to exist. In their absence, they cease to exist.”
爾時,帝釋即白佛言:「實 爾。世尊!貪嫉之生,皆由愛憎,愛憎為因,愛憎 為緣,愛憎為首,從此而有,無此則無。我今 聞佛所說,迷惑悉除,無復疑也。 32. Lord Śakra then said to the Buddha, “Indeed, it is, Bhagavān! The arising of greed and jealousy have their origin in love and hate. Love and hate are their causes and conditions. Love and hate are their source. From them, they come to exist. In their absence, they cease to exist. Now that I’ve heard the Buddha’s explanation, my confusion is completely removed. I won’t wonder about it anymore.
但不解 愛憎復何由而生?何因何緣?誰為原首?從 誰而有?從誰而無?」 33. “But I don’t understand the arising of love and hate. What are their causes and conditions? What is their source? From what do they come to exist? From what do they cease to exist?”
佛告帝釋:「愛憎之生,皆 由於欲,因欲緣欲,欲為原首,從此而有,無 此則無。」 34. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “The arising of love and hate has its origin in desire. Desire is their cause and condition. Desire is their source. From this, they come to exist. In its absence, they cease to exist.”
爾時,帝釋白佛言:「實爾!世尊!愛憎之 生,皆由於欲,因欲緣欲,欲為原首,從此而 有,無此則無。我今聞佛所說,迷惑悉除,無 復疑也。 35. Lord Śakra then said to the Buddha, “Indeed, it is, Bhagavān! The arising of love and hate has its origin in desire. Desire is their cause and condition. Desire is their source. From this, they come to exist. In its absence, they cease to exist. Now that I’ve heard the Buddha’s explanation, my confusion is completely removed. I won’t wonder about it anymore.
但不知此欲復何由生?何因何 緣?誰為原首?從誰而有?從誰而無?」 36. “But I don’t understand the arising of desire. What are its causes and conditions? What is its source? From what does it come to exist? From what does it cease to exist?”
佛告帝 釋:「愛由想生,因想緣想,想為原首,從此而 有,無此而無。」 37. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “Craving arises from conception. Conception is its cause and condition. Conception is its source. From this, it comes to exist. In its absence, it ceases to exist.”
爾時,帝釋白佛言:「實爾!世尊! 愛由想生,因想緣想,想為原首,從此而有, 無此則無。我今聞佛所說,無復疑也。 38. Lord Śakra then said to the Buddha, “Indeed, it is, Bhagavān! Craving arises from conception. Conception is its cause and condition. Conception is its source. From this, it comes to exist. In its absence, it ceases to exist. Now that I’ve heard the Buddha’s explanation[, my confusion is completely removed.] I won’t wonder about it anymore.
但不 解想復何由而生?何因何緣?誰為原首?從 誰而有?從誰而無?」 39. “But I don’t understand the arising of conception. What are its causes and conditions? What is its source? From what does it come to exist? From what does it cease to exist?”
佛告帝釋:「想之所生,由 於調戲,因調緣調,調為原首,從此而有,無 此則無。 40. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “The conception that gives rise to it has its origin in error.17 Error is its cause and condition. Error is its source. From this, it comes to exist. In its absence, it ceases to exist.
帝釋!若無調戲則無想,無想則無 欲,無欲則無愛憎,無愛憎則無貪嫉,若 無貪嫉,則一切眾生不相傷害。 41. “Śakra, if there’s no error, then there’s no conception. Without conception, there’s no desire. Without desire, there’s no love or hate. Without love or hate, there’s no greed or jealousy. If there’s no greed and jealousy, then sentient beings wouldn’t hurt each other.
帝釋!但緣 調為本,因調緣調,調為原首,從此有想, 從想有欲,從欲有愛憎,從愛憎有貪嫉; 以貪嫉故,使群生等共相傷害。」 42. “Śakra, it’s only the condition of error that’s the root of this. Error is its cause and condition. Error is its source. From this, there is conception. From conception, there is desire. From desire, there is love and hate. From love and hate, there is greed and jealousy. Because of greed and jealousy, sentient beings are led to hurt each other.”
帝釋白佛 言:「實爾!世尊!由調有想,因調緣調,調為原 首,從此有想由調而有,無調則無。 43. Lord Śakra then said to the Buddha, “Indeed, it is, Bhagavān! Error is the origin of conception. Error is its cause and condition. Error is its source. From this, there is conception. Error is the origin of its existence. In the absence of error, it ceases to exist.
若本無 調者則無想,無想則無欲,無欲則無愛憎, 無愛憎則無貪嫉,無貪嫉則一切群生不 相傷害。 44. “If there were no error in the first place, then there wouldn’t be conception. Without conception, there wouldn’t be desire. Without desire, there wouldn’t be love and hate. Without love and hate, there wouldn’t be greed and jealousy. If there were no greed and jealousy, then sentient beings wouldn’t hurt each other.
但想由調生,因調緣調,調為原首, 從調有想,從想有欲,從欲有愛憎,從愛 憎有貪嫉,從貪嫉使一切眾生共相傷 害。我今聞佛所說,迷惑悉除,無復疑也。」 45. “It’s only because of error that conception arises. Error is its cause and condition. Error is its source. From this, there is conception. From conception, there is desire. From desire, there is love and hate. From love and hate, there is greed and jealousy. It’s because of greed and jealousy that all sentient beings are led to hurt each other. Now that I’ve heard the Buddha’s explanation, my confusion is completely removed. I won’t wonder about it anymore.”
The Nature of Error
爾 時,帝釋復白佛言:「一切沙門、婆羅門盡除調 戲在滅迹耶?為不除調戲在滅迹耶?」 46. Lord Śakra again asked the Buddha, “Do all the ascetics and priests on the path to cessation completely eliminate error, or is error not eliminated on the path to cessation?”
佛 告帝釋:「一切沙門、婆羅門不盡除調戲在 滅迹也。所以然者?帝釋,世間有種種界,眾 生各依己界,堅固守持,不能捨離,謂己為 實,餘者為虛。是故,帝釋!一切沙門、婆羅門 不盡除調戲而在滅迹。」 47. The Buddha addressed Lord Śakra, “Not all the ascetics and the priests on the path of cessation completely eliminate error. Why is this? Lord Śakra, the world has a variety of realms, and sentient beings depend on their own realms, firmly defending them. They aren’t able to abandon them. They say, ‘Mine is true; the rest is false.’ Therefore, Lord Śakra, not all the ascetics and priests on the path to cessation entirely eliminate error.”
爾時,帝釋白佛言: 「實爾!世尊!世間有種種眾生,各依己界,堅 固守持,不能捨離,謂己為是,餘為虛妄。是 故一切沙門、婆羅門不盡除調戲而在滅 迹。我聞佛言,疑惑悉除,無復疑也。」 48. Lord Śakra then said to the Buddha, “Indeed, it is, Bhagavān! The world has a variety of sentient beings, and each depends on their own realm, firmly defending it. They aren’t able to abandon them. They say, ‘Mine is true; the rest is false.’ Therefore, not all the ascetics and priests on the path to cessation entirely eliminate error. Hearing the Buddha’s words, my confusion is completely eliminated. I won’t wonder about it anymore.”
帝釋復 白佛言:「齊幾調在滅迹耶?」 49. Lord Śakra again asked the Buddha, “How many kinds of error are there on the path to cessation?”
佛告帝釋:「調 戲有三:一者口,二者想,三者求。彼口所言, 自害、害他,亦二俱害。捨此言已,如所言,不 自害、不害他、不二俱害。知時比丘如口所 言,專念不亂, 50. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “There are three kinds of error: First is speech, second are concepts, and third are pursuits. Speech is words that harm oneself, harm others, and harm both oneself and others. When these words are abandoned, one’s words don’t harm oneself, don’t harm others, and don’t harm both oneself and others. When that’s known, a monk’s words are such that he focuses his attention and isn’t distracted.
想亦自害、害他,亦二俱害;捨 此想已,如所想,不自害、不害他,二俱不 害,知時比丘如所想,專念不亂。帝釋!求亦 自害、害他,亦二俱害; 51. “[Some] concepts also harm oneself, harm others, and harm both oneself and others. Abandoning these concepts, one’s conception is such that it doesn’t harm oneself, doesn’t harm others, and doesn’t harm oneself and others. When he knows this, the monk’s conception is such that he focuses his attention and isn’t distracted.
捨此求已,如所求, 不自害、不害他,不二俱害,知時比丘如 所求,專念不亂。」 52. “Lord Śakra, pursuits also harm oneself, harm others, and harm both oneself and others. Abandoning these pursuits, one’s pursuits are such that they don’t harm oneself, don’t harm others, and don’t harm both oneself and others. When he knows this, the monk’s pursuits are such that he focuses his attention and isn’t distracted.”
爾時,釋提桓因言:「我聞佛 所說,無復狐疑。」 53. Śakra the Lord of Gods then said, “Having heard the Buddha’s explanation, I won’t wonder about this anymore.”
Noble Detachment
又白佛言:「齊幾名賢聖捨 心?」 54. He also asked the Buddha, “How many kinds of noble detachment are there?”
佛告帝釋:「捨心有三:一者喜身,二者憂 身,三者捨身。帝釋!彼喜身者,自害、害他,亦 二俱害;捨此喜已,如所喜,不自害、害他, 二俱不害,知時比丘專念不忘,即名受具 足戒。 55. The Buddha addressed Lord Śakra, “There are three kinds of detachment. One is the body of joy, second is the body of sorrow, and third is the body of equanimity. Lord Śakra, that body of joy harms oneself, harms others, and harms both oneself and others. After becoming detached from this joy, such joy as that doesn’t harm oneself, doesn’t harm others, and doesn’t harm both oneself and others. When he knows this, the monk focuses his attention and doesn’t lose it. That’s called accepting the complete precepts.
帝釋!彼憂身者,自害、害彼,亦二俱害; 捨此憂已,如所憂,不自害、害他,二俱不 害,知時比丘專念不忘,即名受具足戒。 56. “Lord Śakra, that body of sorrow harms oneself, harms others, and harms both oneself and others. After becoming detached from this sorrow, such sorrow as that doesn’t harm oneself, doesn’t harm others, and doesn’t harm oneself and others. When he knows this, the monk focuses his attention and doesn’t lose it. That’s called accepting the complete precepts.
復 次,帝釋!彼捨身者,自害、害他,亦二俱害;捨 此身已,如所捨,不自害、不害他,二俱不 害,知時比丘專念不忘,是即名為受具足 戒。」 57. “Furthermore, Lord Śakra, that body of equanimity harms oneself, harms others, and harms both oneself and others. After becoming detached from this equanimity, such equanimity as that doesn’t harm oneself, doesn’t harm others, and doesn’t harm both oneself and others. When he knows this, the monk focuses his attention and doesn’t lose it. That’s called accepting the complete precepts.”
帝釋白佛言:「我聞佛所說,無復狐疑。」 58. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “Having heard the Buddha’s explanation, I won’t wonder about this anymore.”
Perfection of the Sense Faculties
又 白佛言:「齊幾名賢聖律諸根具足?」 59. He also asked the Buddha, “How many things are called ‘the noble Vinaya’s perfection of the faculties’?”
佛告帝 釋:「眼知色,我說有二:可親、不可親。耳聲、鼻 香、舌味、身觸、意法,我說有二:可親、不可親。」 60. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “The eye perceives form, which I say are of two kinds: approachable and unapproachable. The ear … sounds … nose … odors … tongue … flavors … body … touches … mind … notions, which I say are of two kinds: approachable and unapproachable.”
爾時,帝釋白佛言:「世尊!如來略說,未廣分 別,我以具解。眼知色,我說有二:可親、不可 親。耳聲、鼻香、舌味、身觸、意法有二:可親、不 可親。 61. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “Bhagavān, without a detailed discernment of this concise statement by the Tathāgata, I don’t fully understand, ‘The eye perceives form, which I say are of two kinds: approachable and unapproachable. The ear … sounds … nose … odors … tongue … flavors … body … touches … mind … notions, which I say are of two kinds: approachable and unapproachable.’
世尊!如眼觀色,善法損減,不善法增, 如此眼知色,我說不可親;耳聲、鼻香、舌味、 身觸、意知法,善法損減,不善法增,我說不 可親。 62. “Bhagavān, when skillful qualities decrease and unskillful qualities increase as the eye observes forms, I would say this is the same as the eye perceiving forms that are unapproachable. When skillful qualities decrease and unskillful qualities increase as the ear … sounds … nose … odors … tongue … flavors … body … touches … mind … notions, I would say they are unapproachable.
世尊!如眼見色,善法增長,不善法減, 如是眼知色,我說可親;耳聲、鼻香、舌味、身 觸、意知法,善法增長,不善法減,我說可親。」 63. “Bhagavān, when skillful qualities increase and unskillful qualities decrease as the eye sees form, I would say this is the same as the eye perceiving forms are that approachable. When skillful qualities increase and unskillful qualities decrease as the ear … sounds … nose … odors … tongue … flavors … body … touches … mind … notions, I would say they are approachable.”
佛告帝釋:「善哉!善哉!是名賢聖律諸根具 足。」 64. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “Good, good! This is called ‘the noble Vinaya’s perfection of the faculties’.”
帝釋白佛言:「我聞佛所說,無復狐疑。」 65. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “Hearing the Buddha’s explanation, I won’t wonder about this anymore.”
The Ultimate Goal
復 白佛言:「齊幾比丘名為究竟、究竟梵行、究 竟安隱、究竟無餘?」 66. Again, he asked the Buddha, “How many things does a monk call ‘the ultimate goal, the ultimate goal of the religious life, the ultimate goal of peace, and the ultimate goal that has no remainder’?”
佛告帝釋:「為愛所苦,身 得滅者,是為究竟、究竟梵行、究竟安隱、究 竟無餘。」 67. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “To personally extinguish the suffering caused by craving is the ultimate goal, the ultimate goal of the religious life, the ultimate goal of peace, and the ultimate goal that has no remainder.”
帝釋白佛言:「我本長夜,所懷疑網, 今者如來開發所疑。」 68. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “In the long night of the past, I was caught in a snare of doubt. Now, the Buddha has released me from that doubt.”
The Buddha Questions Lord Śakra
佛告帝釋:「汝昔頗曾 詣沙門、婆羅門所問此義不?」 69. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “Haven’t you visited ascetics and priests to ask about this subject?”
帝釋白佛言: 「我自憶念:昔者,曾詣沙門、婆羅門所諮問此 義。昔我一時曾集講堂,與諸天眾共論:『如 來為當出世,為未出世?』 70. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “I remember that once I visited an ascetic or priest to inquire about this subject. One time, I and the assembly of gods had gathered in the meeting hall and discussed ‘Will a Tathāgata arise in the world? Has he arisen yet?’
時共推求,不見如 來出現于世,各自還宮,五欲娛樂。世尊!我 復於後時見諸大神天,自恣五欲已,漸各 命終。 71. “We looked for him, but we didn’t see a Tathāgata that had arisen in the world. Each of us returned to the palace and entertained ourselves with the five desires. Bhagavān, after that I watched the great spirits and gods freely partake of the five desires, and gradually each of their lives ended.
時我,世尊!懷大恐怖,衣毛為竪。時, 見沙門、婆羅門處在閑靜,去家離欲,我尋 至彼所問言:『云何名究竟?』 72. “At that point, Bhagavān, I felt great apprehension, and my hair stood on end. Then I saw an ascetic or priest dwelling in quietude who had left home and parted with desire. I went quickly to him and asked, ‘What is called the ultimate goal?’
我問此義,彼不 能報。彼既不知,逆問我言:『汝為是誰?』 73. “I asked about this subject, but he couldn’t answer me. Since he didn’t know, he countered by asking me, ‘Who are you?’
我尋 報言:『我是釋提桓因。』 “I immediately replied, ‘I am Śakra the Lord of Gods.’
彼復問言:『汝是何釋?』 74. “Again, he asked, ‘How are you Śakra?’
我 時答言:『我是天帝釋,心有所疑,故來相問 耳。』 “I then answered, ‘I am the Lord God Śakra. I have a doubt in my mind, so I came here to ask you about it.’
時,我與彼如所知見,說於釋義。彼問 我言:『更為我弟子,我今是佛弟子,得須陀 洹道,不墮餘趣,極七往返,必成道果,唯願 世尊記我為斯陀含。』 75. “Then the two of us came to an understanding, discussing the meaning of being Śakra. He would ask, I would answer, and then he would become my disciple. But I’m a disciple of the Buddha, and I’ve attained the path of stream entry. I won’t fall to other destinies, and I’ll surely achieve the fruit of the path in not more than seven rebirths. Please, Bhagavān, describe to me how to become a once-returner!”
說此語已,復作頌 曰: 76. After describing this conversation, Śakra also spoke these verses:
  • 「『由彼染穢想,
    故生我狐疑;
    長夜與諸天,
    推求於如來。
  • “From that defiled notion,
    My misgivings arose as a result.
    During the long night with the gods,
    We went looking for the Tathāgata.
  •   見諸出家人,
    常在閑靜處;
    謂是佛世尊,
    故往𥡳首言:
  • Meeting the renunciants
    Always dwelling in quietude,
    I said, ‘This is the Buddha, the Bhagavān!’
    Going and bowing to them, I asked:
  •   我今故來問,
    云何為究竟?
    問已不能報,
    道迹之所趣。
  • ‘I’ve come to ask a question,
    “What is the ultimate goal?”’
    Asked that, they can’t answer
    About the destination of the path.
  •   今日無等尊,
    是我久所求;
    已觀察己行,
    心已正思惟。
  • This unequalled sage today
    Is who I’ve been seeking for so long.
    Already, I’ve investigated my conduct;
    My mind is thinking correctly!
  •   唯聖先已知,
    我心之所行;
    長夜所修業,
    願淨眼記之。
  • Indeed, the noble one already knew
    The intentions in my mind;
    I’ve cultivated them during the long night.
    Please describe it with the pure eye!
  •   歸命人中上,
    三界無極尊;
    能斷恩愛刺,
    今禮日光尊。』」
  • Homage to the highest of humans,
    The incomparable sage of three realms!
    Cutting the thorns of attachment and craving,
    I bow to the sunlight of the sage!”
佛告帝釋:「汝憶本得喜樂、念樂時不?」 77. The Buddha asked Lord Śakra, “Do you recall a time in the past when you felt joy and happiness?”
帝釋 答曰:「如是,世尊!憶昔所得喜樂、念樂。世尊! 我昔曾與阿須輪共戰,我時得勝,阿須輪 退,我時則還,得歡喜、念樂,計此歡喜、念樂, 離有穢惡刀杖喜樂、鬪訟喜樂。今我於佛 所得喜、念樂,無有刀杖、諍訟之樂。」 78. Lord Śakra answered, “Yes, Bhagavān, I recall a time in the past when I felt joy and happiness. Bhagavān, it was when once I did battle with the asuras, and they retreated when I was victorious. When I returned, I rejoiced and was happy. I imagined that joy and happiness to be separate from the defiled joy and happiness of evil weapons or battle, but now I’ve attained joy and happiness from the Buddha, which lacks any of the pleasures of weaponry and conflict.”
佛告 帝釋:「汝今得喜樂、念樂,於中欲求何功德 果?」 79. The Buddha told Lord Śakra, “Now that you’ve experienced this joy and happiness, what fruits of virtue are you going to pursue?”
爾時,帝釋白佛言:「我於喜樂、念樂中,欲 求五功德果,何等五?」 80. Lord Śakra said to the Buddha, “From that joy and happiness, I’m going to pursue five fruits of virtue. What are the five?”
即說偈言: 81. He then spoke in verse:
  • 「我後若命終,
    捨於天上壽;
    處胎不懷患,
    使我心歡喜。
  • “After the end of my life
    When I discard this life in heaven,
    Dwelling in a womb untroubled
    Will make me feel glad.
  •  佛度未度者,
    能說正真道;
    於三佛法中,
    我要修梵行。
  • The Buddha saves those yet to be saved;
    He teaches the correct and true path.
    In the Completely Awakened One’s teaching,
    I’ll need to cultivate the religious life.
  •  以智慧身居,
    心自見正諦;
    得達本所起,
    於是長解脫。
  • I will personally live with wisdom;
    My heart’s view will be the right truth.
    I’ll comprehend what arose in the past;
    Here, I’ll be liberated for a long time.
  •  但當勤修行,
    習佛真實智;
    設不獲道證,
    功德猶勝天。
  • I’ll just cultivate the practice diligently;
    I’ll develop the Buddha’s real knowledge.
    Even if I don’t obtain realization of the path,
    The virtue will still be of a higher heaven.
  •  諸有神妙天,
    阿迦尼吒等;
    下至末後身,
    必當生彼處。
  • There are gods of sublime heavens
    Such as those in Akaniṣṭha;
    When I reach my last incarnation,
    It’ll surely be in those places.
  •  我今於此處,
    受天清淨身;
    復得增壽命,
    淨眼我自知。」
  • Now, I’m here in this place,
    Having gotten a heavenly pure body.
    But I’ll obtain a longer life,
    I know it myself using the pure eye.”
說此偈已,白佛言:「我於喜樂、念樂中,欲得 如是五功德果。」 82. After speaking these verses, he said to the Buddha, “I want to obtain the fruits of these five virtues from this joy and happiness.”
Conclusion
爾時,帝釋語忉利諸天曰:「汝 於忉利天上梵童子前恭敬禮事,今於佛 前復設此敬者,不亦善哉!」 83. Lord Śakra then said to the Trāyastriṃśa gods, “You’ve venerated in front of Brahmā Kumāra above the Trāyastriṃśa heaven before. Wouldn’t it be excellent to also venerate in front of the Buddha?”
其語未久時, 梵童子忽然於虛空中天眾上立,向天帝 釋而說偈曰: 84. Soon after he said this, Brahmā Kumāra instantly appeared standing in the sky above the host of gods. He spoke this verse to Lord Śakra:
  • 「天王清淨行,
    多利益眾生;
    摩竭帝釋主,
    能問如來義。」
  • “The god king’s practice is pure;
    It blesses many sentient beings.
    Lord Śakra of Magadha
    Asked the Tathāgata about his meaning.”
時,梵童子說此偈已,忽然不現。是時,帝釋 即從座起,禮世尊足,遶佛三匝,却行而退, 忉利諸天及般遮翼亦禮佛足,却行而退。 85. After saying this verse, Brahmā Kumāra instantly disappeared. Lord Śakra then rose from his seat, bowed at the Buddha’s feet, circled him three times, withdrew, and walked away. The Trāyastriṃśa gods and Pañcaśikha also bowed at the Buddha’s feet, withdrew, and walked away.
時, 天帝釋少復前行,顧語般遮翼曰:「善哉!善 哉!汝能先於佛前鼓琴娛樂,然後我及諸 天於後方到,我今知汝補汝父位,於乾沓 和中最為上首,當以彼拔陀乾沓和王 女與汝為妻。」 86. After they walked a little while, Lord Śakra looked over to Pañcaśikha and said, “Good, good! Earlier, you went to the Buddha first and played music by strumming your lute, then later I and the gods arrived behind you. Now I know you will succeed your father’s place as the highest of gandharvas. You shall marry Bhadrā, the gandharva king’s daughter!”
世尊說此法時,八萬四千 諸天遠塵離垢,諸法法眼生。 87. When the Bhagavān spoke this teaching, 84,000 gods had their dust and defilements removed, and the Dharma vision arose in them.
時,釋提桓因、忉 利諸天及般遮翼聞佛所說歡喜,奉行。 88. When Śakra the Lord of Gods, the Trāyastriṃśa gods, and Pañcaśikha heard what the Buddha taught, they rejoiced and approved.
佛說長阿含經卷第十

Notes

  1. This is sūtra no. 14 of the Dīrgha Āgama (T1.1.62b28-6a3). Parallels for this sūtra include DN 21, MĀ 134, T15, T203.73, and a Sanskrit fragment (SF 241. [back]

  2. north of the village … Mount Vaidehaka. C. 摩竭國菴婆羅村北,毘陀山因陀娑羅窟中, P. magadhesu viharati, pācīnato rājagahassa ambasaṇḍā nāma brāhmaṇagāmo, tassuttarato vediyake pabbate indasālaguhāyaṁ. All of the parallels agree more-or-less with this location information, which is somewhat convoluted compared to most Buddhist sūtras. The fact that the extant recensions agree as much as they do shows that this text was quite stable across traditions. A couple of the C. terms here are unclear until we peruse sources in other languages.

    village of Āmra. C. 菴婆羅村 (EMC. •əm-bua-la + “village” = G. *aṃbragrama), P. ambasaṇḍā nāma brāhmaṇagāmo. Here, the name of the village was shortened to simply S. āmra (“mango”), which in G. was sometimes written aṃbra. In light of this, it seems likely to me that 婆羅 was intended to translit. -bra, not -bara or -bala. There is also no mention of brahmins in this version. T15 and T203 both agree with the P. version of this placename, and MĀ 134 only omits mention of brahmins. All three appear to translit. and/or trans. S. āmraṣaṇḍā (“mango grove”).

    Mount Vaidehaka. C. 毘陀山 (EMC. bii-da + “mountain” = G. vida- pavada), P. vediyaka pabbata, S. vaidehaka parvata. I’ve adopted the S. for this mountain’s name, which is attested in the S. fragment edited by Waldschimdt. The version here resembles it, but it appears the end has been clipped off. MĀ 134 translit. something like G. vedadi (= S. vetti, “knows”), T15 translit. G. vedehi, and T203 agrees with T15. Thus, all the parallels agree somehwhat on the first two syllables, but the names had variable endings. It was not a stable placename.

    Indraśaila Cave. C. 因陀娑羅窟 (EMC. •iĕn-da-sa-la = G. *iṃdasala), P. indasālaguhā, S. indraśailaguhā. This placename is well known in later P. and S. sources as a hill cave located somewhere outside of Rājagṛha. What’s most remarkable here is that the translit. 因陀娑羅 is almost exactly the same pronunciation as P. indasāla, even though normally P. inda would become G. iṃdra. MĀ 134 has Indra’s Cave (因陀羅石室), T15 has Lord Śakra’s Crag (帝釋巖), and T203 simply says he was in a cave on Mount Vedehi (毘提醯山石窟之中). These variations suggest that the later tradition is not necessarily the original one, but DĀ 14 certainly agrees with it here. [back]

  3. In DN 21, Sakka approaches the gods of the Tāvatiṁsa Heaven rather than the gods approaching him. However, the other three C. parallels all lack this exchange. Instead, Śakra approaches Pañcaśikha after hearing that the Buddha was staying at the cave on Mount Vaidehaka. The S. fragment appears to proceed in the same fashion as the other C. parallels, but the introduction is missing, so it’s not entirely clear which event comes first in that version. [back]

  4. gandharva Pañcaśikha. C. 執樂神般遮翼, P. pañcasikha gandhabbadevaputta, S. paṁcaśikha gandharvaputra. The C. here trans. gandharva as music (樂) bearing (執) spirit (神). Pañcaśikha is translit. as EMC. buan-tʃɪă-yiək, which perhaps renders something like Pr. paṃcayik[ha], where the -ś- had become a -y- or gone silent. Lit., S. pañcaśikha is generally considered to mean “five crests,” though MĀ 134 and T15 both translate śikha as “topknot.” [back]

  5. the Bhagavān had entered the samādhi of blazing fire. This attribution of the fiery light on the mountain to the Buddha is only found in this version of the sūtra. All the others, including DN 21, imply that it was the glow of the assembly of gods. [back]

  6. Bhadrā … your father. Bhadrā was the daughter of the king of gandharvas. Śakra indicates at the conclusion of the present sūtra that Pañcaśikha was her suitor. [back]

  7. This verse is nearly identical to verse 11 in DN 21. Verse 7 in MĀ 134 is similar but references a sage attaining awakening in the second couplet. In T15, verse 4 is changed even more, referencing an arhat delighting in the way of peace. The first couplet of verse 2 in T203.73 also references an arhat’s love of the Dharma. Verse 2 in the Sanskrit fragment reads very similar to MĀ 134. [back]

  8. This verse is very similar to verse 6 in DN 21, but here the animal hooked is an elephant, not a fish. In T15, the second couplet of verse 3 includes the example of an elephant controlled with a hook, but not in the same context. The first verse in T203.73 likewise uses the image of an elephant and a hook, but there it’s a rutting elephant that can’t be controlled in that way. [back]

  9. This and the previous verse contain most of the similes of relief found in verses 2 and 3 of DN 21: the cool wind, cool drink of water, water dousing fire, medicine for the sick, food for the starving, and the Dharma to an arhat. Verse 2 and 9 of MĀ 134 mention all of these similes, too. T15 mentions the wind, drink, medicine, food, and the arhat in verses 2-4, but there’s more variation evident. Several of these similes also occur in T203.73 verses 3 and 4: the wind, drink, arhat, medicine, and food. Instead of a fire, Pañcaśikha’s fever is doused. [back]

  10. This verse has some similarity with verse 5 of DN 21, but there the elephant defeats weapons rather than a handler’s hook, and the second couplet references being crazy about a woman’s attractiveness. Verse 5 of MĀ 134 instead references a shackled elephant that powerless, which is likened to the woman not responding to the suitor’s efforts. Verse 1 in T203 has a simile of a maddened elephant that can’t be controlled with the hook. [back]

  11. Verse 4 in both DN 21 and MĀ 134 present similes of elephants refreshing themselves in ponds. All three versions mention water plants in the pond and the elephants bathing, but only DN 21 turns this into a simile about Pancasikha’s desire. [back]

  12. This verse corresponds to verse 9 in both DN 21 and MĀ 134 and verse 3 in T15. Strangely, DN 21 repeats this verse in verse 4 by changing the second line to a different kind of merit. [back]

  13. This verse, with a sentiment so universal to the human condition of being in love, is not found in DN 21, but it matches verse 10 in MĀ 134 quite well. One wonders is the second verse on sharing merits in DN 21 hasn’t overwritten it. [back]

  14. This concluding verse matches verse 13 in DN 21 and verse 5 in T15. The conclusion in MĀ 134 jarringly switches to praising the Buddha, and T203 doesn’t conclude with a request for Bhadrā’s hand. [back]

  15. the Ajapāla Nigrodha tree on the bank of the Nairañjanā River in Uruvilvā. C. 鬱鞞羅、尼連禪水邊,阿遊波陀、尼俱律樹, P. uruvelāyaṁ viharati najjā nerañjarāya tīre ajapālanigrodhe. The C. transliterations of these placenames generally agree with DN 21, with some of the usual differences in pronunciation found in other Prakrit languages.

    . C. 阿遊波陀 (EMC. •a-yiəu-pua-da = ayopada?), P. ajapāla. In many G. texts, j > y and l > d when compared to Sanskrit or Pali, so this variation in pronunciation here is not unexpected. The word is interpreted to mean a goatherd in P. sources (i.e., aja + pāla = "goat protector"), but there is no attestation in G. that I have found to confirm the same reading here. I have adopted the S. reading as per my usual policy.

    banyan tree. C. 尼俱律樹 (EMC. ṇɪi-kɪu-lɪuĕt + “tree” = nigro[dha]), P. nigrodha, S. nyagrodha. Here, 俱律 represent the syllable -kro-, and the final syllable has been dropped.

    beside the Nairañjanā River. C. 尼連禪水邊 (EMC. ṇɪi-lɪɛn-ʒɪɛn + “riverside” = niranjan[a]?), P. nerañjarā, S. nairañjanā. The translit. here matches the S. better than it does the P.

    Uruvilvā. C. 鬱鞞羅 (EMC. •ɪuət-bei-la = [ur]uvela?), P. uruvelā, S. uruvilvā. Lacking a G. or other Prakrit attestation, I can only guess that the initial ur- has been omitted from the translit. here. [back]

  16. Śikhaṇḍin. C. 尸漢陀 (EMC. ṣï-han-da = śihanda), P. sikhaṇḍī, S. śikhaṇḍin. Here, the -kh- in this name has weakened to -h-, which is common in G. This character is called a general of the gods here. In the P. tradition, he was the son of a heavenly charioteer, Mātali, who was the love interest of Bhadda in a triangle involving Pañcaśikha. [back]

  17. error. C. 調戲. This is presumably a translation of S. prapañca (P. papañca). This is a difficult term to pin down in Indic sources, being variously interpreted as proliferation, activity, and error or false ideas. The Chinese translation adds to the difficulty because it could be read as restlessness or agitation (S. auddhatya, P. uddhacca) but can mean reckless or wild behavior. Given the way the term appears to take on both epistemological and moral meanings in the passages that follow, I’ve opted for “error” as a translation, assuming the original was indeed S. prapañca. The Japanese translators agree, translating it as “false ideas.” [back]


Translator: Charles Patton

Last Revised: 23 January 2025