The Long Discourses
Part II
| (一三)佛說長阿含第二分大緣方便經第九 | 13. The Great Method of Origination |
|---|---|
| 如是我聞: 一時,佛在拘流沙國劫摩沙住 處,與大比丘眾千二百五十人俱。 | 1. Thus I have heard:1 One time, the Buddha was in Kuru at Kalmāṣa’s Residence2 and accompanied by a great assembly of 1,250 monks. |
| Ānanda’s Question | |
| 爾時,阿難 在閑靜處,作是念言:「甚奇!甚特!世尊所說 十二因緣法之光明,甚深難解,如我意觀, 猶如目前,以何為深?」 | 2. It was then that Ānanda was staying in a quiet place and thought, “Amazing! Extraordinary! The twelve dependent originations that are taught by the Bhagavān are the light of the teaching!3 They are profound and difficult to understand, but my mind observes them as though they were right in front of my eyes. Why are they so profound?” |
| 於是,阿難即從靜室 起,至世尊所,頭面禮足,在一面坐,白世尊 言:「我向於靜室,默自思念:『甚奇!甚特!世尊 所說十二因緣法之光明,甚深難解,如我意 觀,如在目前,以何為深?』」 | 3. Ānanda then emerged from his quiet room, went to the Bhagavān, bowed his head at his feet, and sat to one side. He said to the Bhagavān, “I was in a quiet room and thought to myself, ‘Amazing! Extraordinary! The twelve dependent originations that are taught by the Bhagavān are the light of the teaching! They are profound and difficult to understand, but my mind observes them as though they were right in front of my eyes. Why are they so profound?’” |
| 爾時,世尊告阿 難曰:「止!止!勿作此言:『十二因緣法之光明, 甚深難解!』阿難!此十二因緣難見難知,諸 天、魔、梵、沙門、婆羅門、未見緣者,若欲思量 觀察分別其義者,則皆荒迷,無能見者。 | 4. The Bhagavān then told Ānanda, “Stop, stop! Don’t say, ‘The twelve dependent originations are the light of the teaching. They are profound and difficult to understand.’ Ānanda, these twelve dependent originations are difficult to see and difficult to know. Dependent origination is unknown to the gods, Māra, Brahmā, ascetics, and priests. If they were to ponder, investigate, and discern its meaning, they would become confused, being unable to see it. |
| The Dependent Origination of Suffering | |
| 阿 難!我今語汝老死有緣,若有問言:『何等是 老死緣?』應答彼言:『生是老死緣!』 | 5. “Ānanda, I’ll discuss it with you now. There’s a condition for old age and death. Suppose someone were to ask, ‘What’s the condition for old age and death?’ They should be answered, ‘Birth is the condition for old age and death.’ |
| 若復問 言:『誰是生緣?』應答彼言:『有是生緣。』 | 6. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for birth?’ They should be answered, ‘Existence is the condition for birth.’ |
| 若復問 言:『誰是有緣?』應答彼言:『取是有緣。』 | 7. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for existence?’ They should be answered, ‘Grasping is the condition for existence.’ |
| 若復問 言:『誰是取緣?』應答彼言:『愛是取緣。』 | 8. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for grasping?’ They should be answered, ‘Craving is the condition for grasping.’ |
| 若復 問言:『誰是愛緣?』應答彼言:『受是愛緣。』 | 9. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for craving?’ They should be answered, ‘Feeling is the condition for craving.’ |
| 若 復問言:『誰是受緣?』應答彼言:『觸是受緣。』 | 10. “Suppose they also asked, ‘What’s the condition for feeling?’ They should be answered, ‘Contact is the condition for feeling.’ |
| 若 復問言:『誰為觸緣?』應答彼言:『六入是觸緣。』 | 11. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for contact?’ They should be answered, ‘The six sense fields are the condition for contact.’ |
| 若復問言:『誰為六入緣?』應答彼言:『名色是 六入緣。』 | 12. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for the six sense fields?’ They should be answered, ‘Name and form are the condition for the six sense fields.’ |
| 若復問言:『誰為名色緣?』應答彼言: 『識是名色緣。』 | 13. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for name and form?’ They should be answered, ‘Consciousness is the condition for name and form.’ |
| 若復問言:『誰為識緣?』應答彼 言:『行是識緣。』 | 14. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for consciousness?’ They should be answered, ‘Action is the condition for consciousness.’ |
| 若復問言:『誰為行緣?』應答 彼言:『癡是行緣。』 | 15. “Suppose they also ask, ‘What’s the condition for action?’ They should be answered, ‘Delusion is the condition for action.’ |
| 阿難!如是緣癡有行,緣行 有識,緣識有名色,緣名色有六入,緣六 入有觸,緣觸有受,緣受有愛,緣愛有取, 緣取有有,緣有有生,緣生有老、死、憂、悲、 苦惱,大患所集,是為此大苦陰緣。」 | 16. “Thus, Ānanda, action exists conditioned by delusion. Consciousness exists conditioned by action. Name and form exist conditioned by consciousness. The six sense fields exist conditioned by name and form. Contact exists conditioned by the six sense fields. Feeling exists conditioned by contact. Craving exists conditioned by feeling. Grasping exists conditioned by craving. Existence exists conditioned by grasping. Birth exists conditioned by existence. The formation of the great calamity of old age, death, sorrow, lamentation, pain, and trouble exists conditioned by birth. These are the conditions for this great mass of suffering.” |
| The Dependent Origination of Old Age and Death | |
| 佛告阿 難:「緣生有老死,此為何義?若使一切眾生 無有生者,寧有老死不?」 | 17. The Buddha told Ānanda, “‘Old age and death exist conditioned by birth.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being was subject to birth. Would there be old age and death?” |
| 阿難答曰:「無也。」 | Ānanda replied, “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「是故,阿難!以此緣,知老死由生,緣生有 老死,我所說者,義在於此。」 | 18. “Therefore, Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know old age and death comes from birth. ‘Old age and death exist conditioned by birth.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 又告阿難:「緣有 有生,此為何義?若使一切眾生無有欲有、 色無色有者,寧有生不?」 | 19. He also told Ānanda, “‘Birth exists conditioned by existence.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any existence in the desire realm or in the form or formless realms. Would there be birth?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我 以此緣,知生由有,緣有有生,我所說者,義 在於此。」 | 20. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know birth comes from existence. ‘Birth exists conditioned by existence.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 又告阿難:「緣取有有,此為何義? 若使一切眾生無有欲取、見取、戒取、我取者, 寧有有不?」 | 21. He also told Ānanda, “‘Existence exists conditioned by grasping.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any grasping of desires, views, precepts, or self. Would there be existence?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知有 由取,緣取有有,我所說者,義在於此。」 | 22. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know existence comes from grasping. ‘Existence exists conditioned by grasping.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 又告 阿難:「緣愛有取,此為何義?若使一切眾生 無有欲愛、有愛、無有愛者,寧有取不?」 | 23. He also told Ānanda, “‘Grasping exists conditioned by craving.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any craving for desires, existences, or non-existence. Would there be clinging?” |
| 答曰: 「無有。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知取由愛,緣愛有 取,我所說者,義在於此。」 | 24. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know grasping comes from craving. ‘Grasping exists conditioned by craving.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 又告阿難:「緣受有 愛,此為何義?若使一切眾生無有樂受、苦 受、不苦不樂受者,寧有愛不?」 | 25. He also told Ānanda, “‘Craving exists conditioned by feeling.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any pleasant, painful, or neither pleasant nor painful feelings. Would there be craving?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿 難!我以此緣,知愛由受,緣受有愛,我所 說者,義在於此。 | 26. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know craving comes from feeling. ‘Craving exists conditioned by feeling.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| The Dependent Origination of Weapons and Fighting | |
| 阿難!當知因愛有求,因求 有利,因利有用,因用有欲,因欲有著,因 著有嫉,因嫉有守,因守有護。阿難!由有 護故,有刀杖、諍訟、作無數惡,我所說者,義 在於此。 | 27. “Ānanda, you should know that seeking exists because of craving. Profit exists because of seeking. Use exists because of profit. Desire exists because of use. Attachment exists because of desire. Jealousy exists because of attachment. Guarding exists because of jealousy. Safeguards exist because of guarding. Ānanda, weapons, fighting, and the making of countless evils come from the existence of safeguards. That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!此為何義,若使一切眾生無 有護者,當有刀杖、諍訟,起無數惡不?」 | 28. “Ānanda, what does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any safeguards. Would there be weapons, fighting, and the arising of countless evils?” |
| 答 曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「是故,阿難!以此因緣,知刀杖、諍訟 由護而起,緣護有刀杖、諍訟。阿難!我所說 者,義在於此。」 | 29. “Therefore, Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know weapons and fighting are produced from safeguards. ‘Weapons and fighting exist conditioned by safeguards.’ Ānanda, that’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 又告阿難:「因守有護,此為 何義?若使一切眾生無有守者,寧有護不?」 | 30. He also told Ānanda, “‘Safeguards exist conditioned by guarding.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had anything to guard. Would there be safeguards?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知護由守,因守 有護,我所說者,義在於此。 | 31. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know safeguards come from guarding. ‘Safeguards exist conditioned by guarding.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!因嫉有守, 此為何義?若使一切眾生無有嫉者,寧有 守不?」 | 32. “Ānanda, ‘guarding exists conditioned by jealousy.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any jealousy. Would there be guarding?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知守由 嫉,因嫉有守,我所說者,義在於此。 | 33. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know guarding comes from jealousy. ‘Guarding exists conditioned by jealousy.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!因 著有嫉,此為何義?若使一切眾生無有著 者,寧有嫉不?」 | 34. “Ānanda, ‘jealousy exists conditioned by attachment.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any attachments. Would there be jealousy?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知 嫉由著,因著有嫉,我所說者,義在於此。 | 35. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know jealousy comes from attachment. ‘Jealousy exists conditioned by attachment.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿 難!因欲有著,此為何義?若使一切眾生無 有欲者,寧有著不?」 | 36. “Ānanda, ‘attachment exists conditioned by desire.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any desire. Would there be attachment?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此 緣,知著由欲,因欲有著,我所說者,義在 於此。 | 37. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know attachment comes from desire. ‘Attachment exists conditioned by desire.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!因用有欲,此為何義?若使一 切眾生無有用者,寧有欲不?」 | 38. “Ānanda, ‘desire exists conditioned by use.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had use [for anything]. Would there be desire?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿 難,我以此義,知欲由用,因用有欲,我所 說者,義在於此。 | 39. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know desire comes from use. ‘Desire exists conditioned by use.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!因利有用,此為何義, 若使一切眾生無有利者,寧有用不?」 | 40. “Ānanda, ‘use exists conditioned by profit.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any profit. Would there be something to use?” |
| 答曰:「無 也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此義,知用由利,因利有用, 我所說者,義在於此。 | 41. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know use comes from profit. ‘Use exists conditioned by profit.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!因求有利,此為 何義?若使一切眾生無有求者,寧有利不?」 | 42. “Ānanda, ‘profit exists conditioned by seeking.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had [anything to] seeking. Would there be profit?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知利由求,因求 有利,我所說者,義在於此。 | 43. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know profit comes from seeking. ‘Profit exists conditioned by seeking.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!因愛有 求,此為何義?若使一切眾生無有愛者,寧 有求不?」 | 44. He also told Ānanda, “‘Seeking exists conditioned by craving.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any craving. Would there be seeking?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知求由 愛,因愛有求,我所說者,義在於此。」 | 45. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know seeking comes from craving. ‘Seeking exists conditioned by craving.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 又告 阿難:「因愛有求,至於守護,受亦如是,因受 有求,至於守護。」 | 46. He also told Ānanda, “Seeking exists conditioned by craving up to guarding and safeguards. Feeling is likewise. Seeking exists because of feeling up to guarding and safeguards.” |
| The Dependent Origination of Feeling | |
| 佛告阿難:「緣觸有受,此 為何義?阿難!若使無眼、無色、無眼識者, 寧有觸不?」 | 47. The Buddha told Ānanda, “‘Feeling exists conditioned by contact.’ What does this mean? Suppose that there were no eye, form, and visual consciousness. Would there be contact?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「若無耳、聲、耳識,鼻、香、 鼻識,舌、味、舌識,身、觸、身識,意、法、意識者,寧 有觸不?」 | 48. “Suppose that there were no ear, sound, or auditory consciousness … no nose, odor, or olfactory consciousness … no tongue, flavor, or gustatory consciousness … no body, touch, or somatic consciousness … no mind, notion, or cognitive consciousness. Would there be contact?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!若使一切眾生無 有觸者,寧有受不?」 | 49. “Ānanda, suppose that no sentient being had any contact. Would there be feeling?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以是 義,知受由觸,緣觸有受,我所說者,義在於 此。 | 50. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know feeling comes from contact. ‘Feeling exists conditioned by contact.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!緣名色有觸,此為何義?若使一切 眾生無有名色者,寧有心觸不?」 | 51. “Ānanda, ‘contact exists conditioned by name and form.’ What does this mean? Suppose that no sentient being had any name and form. Would there be mental contact?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「若使一切眾生無形色相貌者,寧有身觸 不?」 | 52. “Suppose that no sentient being had any physical form or appearance. Would there be physical contact? |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!若無名色,寧有觸不?」 | 53. “Ānanda, suppose that there were no name and form. Would there be contact? |
| 答 曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以是緣,知觸由名色,緣名 色有觸,我所說者,義在於此。 | 54. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know contact comes from name and form. ‘Contact exists conditioned by name and form.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!緣識有 名色,此為何義?若識不入母胎者,有名色 不?」 | 55. “Ānanda, ‘name and form exist conditioned by consciousness.’ What does this mean? Suppose that consciousness didn’t enter the mother’s womb. Would there be name and form?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「若識入胎不出者,有名色不?」 | 56. “Suppose that consciousness entered the womb but didn’t come out. Would there be name and form?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「若識出胎,嬰孩壞敗,名色得增 長不?」 | 57. “Suppose that consciousness left the womb, but the infant perished. Would name and form grow?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “They wouldn’t.” |
| 「阿難!若無識者,有名色不?」 | 58. “Ānanda, suppose there was no consciousness. Would there be name and form?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以是緣,知名色由識,緣 識有名色,我所說者,義在於此。 | 59. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know name and form comes from consciousness. ‘Name and form exist conditioned by consciousness.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!緣名 色有識,此為何義?若識不住名色,則識 無住處;若無住處,寧有生、老、病、死、憂、悲、苦 惱不?」 | 60. “Ānanda, ‘Consciousness exists conditioned by name and form.’ What does this mean? If consciousness didn’t abide in name and form, then consciousness would have nowhere to reside. If it had nowhere to reside, would there be birth, old age, illness, death, sorrow, lamentation, pain, and trouble?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!若無名色,寧有識不?」 | 61. “Ānanda, if there were no name and form, would there be consciousness?” |
| 答曰:「無也。」 | “There wouldn’t be.” |
| 「阿難!我以此緣,知識由名色, 緣名色有識,我所說者,義在於此。 | 62. “Ānanda, it’s for this reason that we know consciousness comes from name and form. ‘Consciousness exists conditioned by name and form.’ That’s the meaning of what I said. |
| 阿難!是 故名色緣識,識緣名色,名色緣六入,六入 緣觸,觸緣受,受緣愛,愛緣取,取緣有,有 緣生,生緣老、死、憂、悲、苦、惱,大苦陰集。 | 63. “Therefore, Ānanda, name and form conditions consciousness. Consciousness conditions name and form. Name and form conditions the six sense fields. The six sense fields condition contact. Contact conditions feeling. Feeling conditions craving. Craving conditions grasping. Grasping conditions existence. Existence conditions birth. Birth conditions old age, death, sorrow, lamentation, and suffering, which forms the great mass of suffering. |
| Liberation by Wisdom | |
| 「阿難! 齊是為語,齊是為應,齊是為限,齊此為 演說,齊是為智觀,齊是為眾生。 | 64. “Ānanda, this is the extent of language, the extent of answers, the extent of limits, the extent of explanations, the extent of wise observation, and the extent of sentient beings. |
| 阿難!諸比 丘於此法中,如實正觀,無漏心解脫。阿難!此 比丘當名為慧解脫,如是解脫比丘如來終 亦知,如來不終亦知,如來終不終亦知,如來 非終非不終亦知,何以故? | 65. “Ānanda, when monks truly and correctly observe this [series of] principles, their minds will be uncontaminated and liberated. Ānanda, these monks should be called ‘those liberated by wisdom.’ Such a liberated monk also knows that the Tathāgata has an end, knows that the Tathāgata doesn’t have an end, knows that the Tathāgata has and doesn’t have an end, and knows that the Tathāgata neither has nor doesn’t have an end. Why? |
| 阿難!齊是為語, 齊是為應,齊是為限,齊是為演說,齊是 為智觀,齊是為眾生;如是盡知已,無漏心 解脫比丘不知不見如是知見。 | 66. “Ānanda, this is the extent of language, the extent of answers, the extent of limits, the extent of explanations, the extent of wise observation, and the extent of sentient beings. Thus, having fully known it, a liberated monk whose mind is uncontaminated doesn’t know or see such knowing and seeing [of those four alternatives]. |
| The View That Feeling Is Self | |
| 阿難!夫計 我者,齊幾名我見,名色與受,俱計以為我。 | 67. “Ānanda, how many views are there that postulate a self? Name and form and feeling are both taken to be the self. |
| 有人言:『受非我,我是受。』或有言:『受非我,我 非受,受法是我。』或有言:『受非我,我非受,受 法非我,但愛是我。』 | 68. “Some people say, ‘Feeling is not self, but the self is feeling.’ Others say, ‘Feeling is not self, the self is not feeling, but what feels is the self.’ Others say, ‘Feeling is not self, the self is not feeling, and what feels is not self. Only craving [for feeling] is the self.’ |
| 「阿難!彼見我者,言受 是我,當語彼言:『如來說三受,樂受、苦受、不 苦不樂受。當有樂受時,無有苦受、不苦不 樂受;有苦受時,無有樂受、不苦不樂受;有 不苦不樂受時,無有苦受、樂受。』 | 69. “Ānanda, someone who has a view of self and says that feeling is self should be told, ‘The Tathāgata teaches that there are three feelings: Pleasant feelings, painful feelings, and feelings that are neither pleasant nor painful. When there’s pleasant feeling, there isn’t any feeling that’s painful or neither pleasant nor painful. When there’s painful feeling, there isn’t any feeling that’s pleasant or neither pleasant nor painful. When there’s feeling that’s neither pleasant nor painful, there isn’t any feeling that’s painful or pleasant.’ |
| 所以然者? 阿難!樂觸緣生樂受,若樂觸滅受亦滅。阿 難!苦觸緣生苦受,若苦觸滅受亦滅;不苦不 樂觸緣生不苦不樂受,若不苦不樂觸滅受 亦滅。 | 70. “Why is that? Ānanda, pleasant contact is the condition that gives rise to pleasant feeling. If pleasant contact ceases, the feeling also ceases. Ānanda, painful contact is the condition that gives rise to painful feeling. If painful contact ceases, the feeling also ceases. Contact that’s neither pleasant nor painful is the condition that gives rise to feeling that’s neither pleasant nor painful. If contact that’s neither pleasant nor painful ceases, the feeling also ceases. |
| 阿難!如兩木相攢則有火生,各置 異處則無有火。此亦如是,因樂觸緣故 生樂受,若樂觸滅受亦俱滅;因苦觸緣故 生苦受,若苦觸滅受亦俱滅;因不苦不樂觸 緣生不苦不樂受,若不苦不樂觸滅受亦俱 滅。 | 71. “Ānanda, it’s like rubbing a pair of sticks together to start a fire. When each stick is put in a different place, there won’t be any fire. This is likewise. Because of the condition of pleasant contact, pleasant feeling arises. If pleasant contact ceases, both it and the feeling cease. Because of the condition of painful contact, painful feeling arises. If painful contact ceases, both it and the feeling cease. Because of the condition of contact that’s neither pleasant nor painful, feeling that’s neither pleasant nor painful arises. If contact that’s neither pleasant nor painful ceases, both it and the feeling cease. |
| 阿難!此三受有為無常,從因緣生,盡法、 滅法,為朽壞法。彼非我有,我非彼有,當 以正智如實觀之。阿難!彼見我者,以受 為我,彼則為非。 | 72. “Ānanda, these three feelings are created and impermanent. They are things that arise from causes and conditions, that end, that cease, and that disintegrate. When truly examined with right knowledge, they are not possessed by self, and the self isn’t possessed by them. Ānanda, the view that takes feeling to be the self is incorrect. |
| The View That Self Is Feeling | |
| 「阿難!彼見我者,言受非我, 我是受者,當語彼言:『如來說三受,苦受、樂 受、不苦不樂受。若樂受是我者,樂受滅時,則 有二我,此則為過。若苦受是我者,苦受滅 時,則有二我,此則為過。若不苦不樂受是 我者,不苦不樂受滅時,則有二我,此則為 過。』 | 73. “Ānanda, some have a view of self and say feeling is not self, but self is feeling. They should be told, ‘The Tathāgata teaches that there are three feelings: Painful feeling, pleasant feeling, and feeling that’s neither pleasant nor painful. If pleasant feeling were the self, then there would be a second self when that pleasant feeling ceases. This then is in error. If painful feeling were the self, then there would be a second self when that painful feeling ceases. This then is in error. If feeling that’s neither pleasant nor painful were the self, then there would be a second self when that feeling that’s neither pleasant nor painful ceases. This then is in error.’ Ānanda, some have a view of a self that says feeling is not self, but self is feeling. It’s not correct. |
| The View That Self Is What Feels | |
| 阿難!彼見我者,言:『受非我,我是受。』彼則 為非。阿難!彼計我者,作此說:『受非我,我非 受,受法是我。』當語彼言:『一切無受。汝云何 言有受法?汝是受法耶?』對曰:『非是。』 | 74. “Ānanda, some who postulate a self make this statement: ‘Feeling is not self, and the self is not feeling, but what feels is the self.’ They should be told, ‘If everything is without feeling, how can you say there’s something that feels? Are you the thing that feels?’ The answer would be, ‘No.’ |
| 是故,阿 難!彼計我者,言:『受非我,我非受,受法是我。』 彼則為非。 | 75. “Therefore, Ānanda, some postulate a self and say feeling is not self, and self is not feeling, but what feels is self. They are incorrect. |
| The View That Craving Is Self | |
| 「阿難!彼計我者,作是言:『受非我, 我非受,受法非我,但愛是我。』者,當語彼言: 『一切無受,云何有愛?汝是愛耶?』對曰:『非 也。』 | 76. “Ānanda, some postulate a self and make this claim, ‘Feeling is not self, the self is not feeling, and what feels is not self. Only the craving is the self.’ They should be told, ‘If everything is without feeling, how would there be craving? Are you this craving?’ The answer would be, ‘No.’ |
| 是故,阿難!彼計我者,言:『受非我,我非受, 受法非我,愛是我。』者,彼則為非。 | 77. “Therefore, Ānanda, some postulate a self and say feeling is not self, the self is not feeling, and what feels is not self, but craving is self. They are incorrect. |
| 阿難!齊是 為語,齊是為應,齊是為限,齊是為演說, 齊是為智觀,齊是為眾生。 | 78. “Ānanda, this is the extent of language, the extent of answers, the extent of limits, the extent of explanations, the extent of wise observation, and the extent of sentient beings. |
| 阿難!諸比丘於 此法中如實正觀,於無漏心解脫。阿難!此 比丘當名為慧解脫,如是解脫心比丘,有 我亦知,無我亦知,有我無我亦知,非有我非 無我亦知。何以故? | 79. “Ānanda, when monks truly and correctly observe this [series of] principles, their minds will be uncontaminated and liberated. Ānanda, these monks should be called ‘those liberated by wisdom.’ Such a liberated monk will know the existence of the self, the non-existence of the self, both the existence and non-existence of the self, and neither the existence nor non-existence of the self. Why? |
| 阿難!齊是為語,齊是為 應,齊是為限,齊是為演說,齊是為智觀, 齊是為眾生;如是盡知已,無漏心解脫比丘 不知不見如是知見。」 | 80. “Ānanda, this is the extent of language, the extent of answers, the extent of limits, the extent of explanations, the extent of wise observation, and the extent of sentient beings. Thus, having fully known it, a liberated monk whose mind is uncontaminated doesn’t know or see such knowing and seeing [of those four alternatives].” |
| Views That Self Is Form and Formless | |
| 佛語阿難:「彼計我者, 齊已為定,彼計我者,或言少色是我,或言多 色是我,或言少無色是我,或言多無色是我。 | 81. The Buddha told Ānanda, “Some who postulate a self have reached the extent of certainty. Postulating a self, they might say, ‘Self is a little bit of form.’ They might say, ‘Self is a large amount of form.’ They might say, ‘Self is something little and formless.’ They might say, ‘Self is something large and formless.’ |
| 阿難!彼言少色是我者,定少色是我,我所 見是,餘者為非。多色是我者,定多色是我, 我所見是,餘者為非。少無色是我者,定言 少無色是我,我所見是,餘者為非。多無色是 我者,定多無色是我,我所見是,餘者為非。」 | 82. “Ānanda, those who say self is a little bit of form are certain that the self is a little bit of form: ‘This is my view of it; anything else is incorrect.’ [Those who say] the self is a large amount of form are certain that the self is a large amount of form: ‘This is my view of it; anything else is incorrect.’ [Those who say] the self is something little and formless are certain the self is something little and formless: ‘This is my view of it; anything else is incorrect.’ [Those who say] the self is something large and formless are certain the self is something large and formless: ‘This is my view of it; anything else is incorrect.’” |
| The Seven Abodes of Consciousness | |
| 佛告阿難:「七識住,二入處,諸有沙門、婆羅門 言:『此處安隱,為救、為護、為舍、為燈、為明、為 歸,為不虛妄,為不煩惱。』云何為七? | 83. The Buddha told Ānanda, “There are seven abodes of consciousness and two spheres. Ascetics and priests say, ‘These abodes are peaceful, saving, protecting, sheltering, lamps, lights, refuges, not false, and not afflicting.’ What are the seven? |
| 或有眾 生,若干種身若干種想,天及人,此是初識住 處。諸沙門、婆羅門言:『此處安隱,為救、為護、 為舍、為燈、為明、為歸,為不虛妄,為不煩 惱。』 | 84. “Some sentient beings have diverse bodies and diverse perceptions. These gods and humans are the first abode of consciousness. Ascetics and priests say, ‘This abode is peaceful, saving, protecting, sheltering, a lamp, a light, a refuge, not false, and not afflicting.’ |
| 阿難!若比丘知初識住,知集、知滅、知 味、知過、知出要,如實知者。阿難!彼比丘言: 『彼非我,我非彼,如實知見。』 | 85. “Ānanda, suppose that a monk knows the first abode of consciousness and knows its formation, cessation, enjoyment, trouble, and escape. Truly knowing it, Ānanda, that monk would say, ‘Truly knowing and seeing it, that’s not self, and the self isn’t that.’ |
| 或有眾生,若干 種身而一想,梵光音天是;或有眾生,一身若 干種想,光音天是;或有眾生一身一想,遍 淨天是;或有眾生,住空處;或有眾生,住識 處;或有眾生,住不用處,是為七識住處。或 有沙門、婆羅門言:『此處安隱,為救、為護、為 舍、為燈、為明、為歸,為不虛妄,為不煩惱。』 | 86. “Some sentient beings have diverse bodies but the same perception. They are Brahmas of the Ābhāsvara Heaven … Some sentient beings have the same body but diverse perceptions. They are in the Ābhāsvara Heaven … Some sentient beings have the same body and the same perception. They are in the Śubhakṛtsnā Heaven … Some sentient beings reside in the abode of space … Some sentient beings reside in the abode of consciousness … Some sentient beings reside in the abode of nothingness. This is the seventh abode of consciousness. Some ascetics and priests say, ‘This abode is peaceful, saving, protecting, sheltering, a lamp, a light, a refuge, not false, and not afflicting.’ |
| 阿 難!若比丘知七識住,知集、知滅、知味、知 過、知出要,如實知見,彼比丘言:『彼非我,我 非彼,如實知見。』是為七識住。 | 87. “Ānanda, suppose that a monk knows the seventh abode of consciousness and knows its formation, cessation, enjoyment, trouble, and escape. Truly knowing it, Ānanda, that monk would say, ‘Truly knowing and seeing it, that’s not self, and the self isn’t that.’ These are the seven abodes of consciousness. |
| The Two Spheres | |
| 「云何二入 處?無想入、非想非無想入。是為,阿難!此二 入處,或有沙門、婆羅門言:『此處安隱,為救、 為護、為舍、為燈、為明、為歸,為不虛妄,為 不煩惱。』 | 88. “What are the two spheres? They are the sphere without perception and the sphere that’s neither perception nor without perception … These are the two spheres, Ānanda. Some ascetics and priests say, ‘This abode is peaceful, saving, protecting, sheltering, a lamp, a light, a refuge, not false, and not afflicting.’ |
| 阿難!若比丘知二入處,知集、知滅、 知味、知過、知出要,如實知見,彼比丘言:『彼 非我,我非彼,如實知見。』是為二入。 | 89. “Ānanda, suppose that a monk knows the two spheres and knows their formation, cessation, enjoyment, trouble, and escape. Truly knowing and seeing them, Ānanda, that monk would say, ‘Truly knowing and seeing it, that’s not self, and the self isn’t that.’ These are the two spheres. |
| The Eight Liberations | |
| 「阿難!復 有八解脫。云何八?色觀色,初解脫。內無色想, 觀外色,二解脫。淨解脫,三解脫。度色想,滅 有對想,不念雜想,住空處,四解脫。度空 處,住識處,五解脫。度識處,住不用處,六解 脫。度不用處,住有想無想處,七解脫。滅盡 定,八解脫。 | 90. “Ānanda, there are also eight liberations. What are the eight? Form observed as form is the first liberation. Observing form externally without an internal perception of form is the second liberation. The liberation of purity is the third liberation. Going beyond perception of forms, ceasing perception of resistance, not attending to diverse perceptions, and abiding in the abode of space is the fourth liberation. Going beyond the abode of space and abiding in the abode of consciousness is the fifth liberation. Going beyond the abode of consciousness and abiding in the abode of nothingness is the sixth liberation. Going beyond the abode of nothingness and abiding in the abode of with and without perception is the seventh liberation. The samādhi of complete cessation is the eighth liberation. |
| 阿難!諸比丘於此八解脫,逆順 遊行,入出自在,如是比丘得俱解脫。」 | 91. “Ānanda, monks who traverse these eight liberations forward and backward, entering and exiting them at will, are monks who’ve attained liberation in both ways.” |
| 爾時,阿 難聞佛所說,歡喜奉行。 | 92. When Ānanda heard what the Buddha taught, he rejoiced and approved. |
Notes
This is sūtra no. 13 of the Dīrgha Āgama (T1.1.60a28-2b27). Parallels for this sūtra include DN 15, MĀ 97, T14, and T52. [back]
Kuru. C. 拘流沙, P. kurūsu, S. kuruṣu.
Kalmāṣa’s Residence. C. 劫摩沙住處, P. kammāsadamma, S. kalmāṣadamya. [back]
While this introduction presents the classic twelve links of dependent origination, there will only be ten links discussed later in the sūtra. When we compare the introductions in the direct parallels, we find four different versions while the body of the sūtra presents the same ten links. This suggests to me that the introduction is a later addition to an older sūtra. [back]
Translator: Charles Patton
Last Revised: 3 November 2026
Previous | Next |